Website carousels remain a popular design choice. However, increasing evidence underscores their adverse effects on crucial metrics such as user engagement, conversion rates, and overall web performance. Here are the essential insights explaining why website carousels can negatively impact your business.
The ineffectiveness of website carousels arises from technical and psychological barriers that harm user experience and conversions. In the following sections, we’ll delve deeper into the data, explore superior alternatives, and outline actionable strategies to optimize your website’s design.
Website carousels persist across the digital environment, but a compelling truth underlies their visually appealing slides: they might harm your business. This isn’t mere speculation; data-backed insights show that website carousels hurt business performance through decreased user engagement and lower conversion rates.
Why might something so seemingly practical have such a negative impact? The answer lies in psychological behaviors such as banner blindness and technical flaws that clash with user experience and website accessibility. As businesses focus on optimizing their online presence for visibility and usability, understanding the pitfalls of carousels is crucial for staying competitive and connecting with your audience effectively. Fortunately, platforms like Onvert offer streamlined solutions for creating high-converting websites and sales funnels without relying on outdated tactics like carousels.
Let’s examine the data-backed evidence, uncover why website carousels fall short, and explore better alternatives to drive user engagement and boost your conversion optimization efforts.
Web users increasingly experience banner blindness, a subconscious tendency to ignore elements that resemble advertisements. This phenomenon, identified by experimental psychologists Johannes Slowitza, Thomas Matzke, and Pamela W. Henderson, has significant implications for website design, especially carousels. Research indicates that nearly 82% of users visually skip carousel content within the first few seconds of landing on a page, attributing this behavior to a self-defense mechanism where users automatically screen out peripheral information.
This banner blindness impacts not just ad banners but dynamic, visually prominent elements like carousels—regardless of design quality or content value. The human brain, conditioned by online experience, instinctively bypasses carousels, treating them as distraction-inducing noise. This is crucial for businesses because even well-executed carousels might invisibly hurt their engagement metrics.
Empirical evidence underscores the detriment to user engagement caused by website carousels. The Nielsen Norman Group found that users often miss key information or ignore critical calls to action embedded within carousel elements. Negti’s research supports this, demonstrating that users are 30% less likely to engage with carousel content compared to static content blocks.
This effect has measurable consequences across various fields. For instance, MailChimp replaced their rotating banner with integrated promotional blocks and observed a 16% increase in user session time. In e-commerce, retailers find that static product displays often outperform carousels in click-through rates and conversions. Similarly, educational platforms might see higher engagement with static course listings rather than rotating promotional carousels. Findings such as these highlight how website carousels hurt business by failing to capture user attention, leading to missed opportunities for engagement and conversion.
Conversion rates, a critical metric for online businesses, are significantly affected by carousels. Nielsen Norman Group’s research highlights that only 1% of visitors interact with the first slide of a carousel, with less than 0.5% engaging with subsequent slides, suggesting businesses sacrifice conversions for additional content display.
Moreover, an A/B test by ConversionXL on an e-commerce website before and after carousel removal was telling. Without the carousel, the page saw a 22% increase in conversions, proving that rotating banner performance directly correlates with reduced conversion rates. This principle applies across industries; whether it’s lead generation in marketing or enrollment rates in education, static, focused content tends to perform better.
Websites must meet digital accessibility guidelines. Unfortunately, carousels often fail when subjected to WCAG standards for accessibility. Fast-moving content can be challenging for users with impaired vision or those using screen readers, as they might not effectively convey the cyclical content, leading to a fragmented user experience.
Furthermore, carousels present usability challenges, particularly on mobile devices where screen real estate is at a premium. Eric Brechner from ServiceTitan shares how an internal study showed mobile users were 56% less likely to engage with carousel content due to physical difficulty in swiping through complex sliders. The onvert.com team has seen success in optimizing sites for mobile by removing carousels, leading to improved engagement and even a 14% higher conversion rate. Onvert helps businesses create mobile-responsive sites that prioritize accessibility and user experience, ensuring content is easily navigable and engaging on any device.
While the user experience and conversion rates take a hit, the technical performance of a website is also compromised by carousels. SlowFlick.com discovered that carousels could increase page load times by up to 94%, significantly impacting user experience metrics like bounce rates. Dell’s internal metric suggested that removing their homepage carousel led to a 25% improvement in page speed and reduced website abandonment.
This loading speed effect influences how users perceive and interact with the site:
It’s not just about removing carousels; it’s about what to replace them with. Businesses need alternatives that marry website accessibility with conversion optimization. Here are some data-backed recommendations:
By transitioning from the traditional website carousel effectiveness model to these innovative, user-focused strategies, businesses can significantly enhance the user experience while maintaining conversion optimization. Platforms like Onvert provide the tools to implement these alternatives easily. From creating engaging landing pages to setting up personalized content modules, Onvert‘s all-in-one platform allows businesses to optimize their online presence for maximum impact.
Website carousels may seem visually appealing initially but come at the expense of user engagement, accessibility, and performance. The data is clear: their inefficacy stems from user behaviors like banner blindness, poor technical performance, and frustrating usability issues. Replacing carousels with smarter design alternatives like static hero images and personalized content can drastically improve engagement, enhance user experience, and drive conversions.
Looking ahead, businesses must shift their design focus toward inclusive, efficient, and actionable practices to remain competitive. As user expectations evolve and technology advances, the ability to adapt and implement user-centric design will separate leaders from followers. Whether it’s through adopting AI-driven content personalization or implementing fully accessible website designs, the future belongs to those who prioritize the user experience above all else. The real question isn’t just whether you’ll retire your carousels—but how effectively you’ll leverage modern design principles to build a website that truly connects with and converts your audience.
Notifications
